INSURANCE AGENCY SERVING Ohio Kentucky, Missouri and Indiana

Get Better Coverage & Better Rates With
Cincinnatus Insurance

Finding the best combination of insurance coverage and cost can be a daunting task. It's why we make the process simple, and explain coverages in terms you can understand, so you know exactly how your money is being spent.

Why Cincinnatus? Here's why:

YouTube video

Quick Quotes & Service

We know your time is valuable which is why we're super quick, yet thorough with everything we do.

Choice Of Carriers

We proactively shop the insurance market place to find you the best combination of cost and coverage.

Technology Focused

Our agency leverages technology to provide you with the client & service experience you deserve.

Cincinnatus Insurance LLC
is truly your partner in protection

IMG_6152 (1)
  • Locally Owned & Operated

    We've been doing business in our community for decades, and when you buy your insurance from us, you're supporting local/small business and a team of people who have a vested interest in your wellbeing.

  • Personalized & Prompt Service

    Are you frustrated and tired of getting the runaround when all you want to do is talk to a human? We know your pain, and it's why we're always here when you have a question or need assistance with a claim or policy change.

  • Here When You Need Us Most

    The entire point of insurance is to protect the lifestyle you've created for yourself with custom insurance protection you can count on in the event of a claim. If the worst were to happen, rest assured, you are our top priority in that moment and nothing else.

Belinda sTONER
a week ago
Our carrier dropped us after we had two claims in seven years. They only gave us a 30 day notice to find other insurance. We...
Bobbie Brandenburg
3 weeks ago
I have had the same agent for years and decided to shop around for a better rate. I am so happy that a friend recommended...
Olivia Kane
a month ago
My fiancé and I are in the process of moving states and needed homeowner & auto insurance. Nick was recommended to us by our real...
YouTube video
YouTube video

If you've felt confused by insurance in the past and want a simpler,
faster option, Cincinnatus Insurance LLC is your solution

Our team of friendly insurance advisors is here to make the process of finding the best
coverage simple. Start a conversation with us today!

Whether it's you, your family or your business, we can create a coverage plan specifically for your unique needs

Personal Insurance

We insure hundreds of families like yours. 

Business Insurance

We insure hundreds of businesses of all shapes and sizes. 

Specialty Insurance

Our agency can also help with specialty insurance coverages.

Insurance is never just about price, but we deliver when it comes to lowering your rates


Our process is simple. Start online, and we'll reach
out to complete your coverage comparison.

Our team of friendly insurance advisors is here to make the process of finding the best
coverage simple. Start a conversation with us today!

  • Start Online

    Enter basic info on our website

  • We Compare Carriers

    We shop multiple carriers for you

  • You Choose

    Pick the coverage package you like best

Call Email Service Center Payments