When it comes to insurance, many people think insurance exists to cover every single bump, leak, and repair. However, we are finding that carriers care more about how often you claim than how expensive your claims are. As a result, filing minor claims on a steady basis can quietly cost you far more than the actual repairs. This guide explains the current insurance climate in regards to claims, and what you can do about it.
Key Takeaways:
- Insurance carriers now focus on how often you file, not only the expense of your claim.
- Multiple small claims can cost you discounts, raise premiums, or even end your policy.
- Paying for small repairs yourself may save you more money over time.
- Always call your advisor at Cincinnatus Insurance with questions about if an incident is indeed a claim.
What Does “Claim Frequency” Mean?
Claim frequency simply means how many claims you file over a set period. Insurance carriers in the standard market often look back three to five years when they review your history. For example, two small claims can look riskier than one larger claim. The reason is fairly simple, because past claims help insurers assess how risky a potential client is, and predict future claims. In other words, in the eyes of an insurance carrier, a small claim is not treated as a small event.
How Can Small Claims Cost You Money?
Filing minor claims on a regular basis can hurt your wallet in several ways, and the effects often stack together.
First, you may lose your claims-free discount, which many home and auto policies include. Second, your carrier may apply a surcharge to your premium, sometimes right away. Third, your insurance company may decide not to renew your policy at all. Then, you must shop for coverage with a claims history that worries other insurers. Consequently, a non-renewal can lead to higher prices and fewer coverage choices.
Insurance carriers check databases such as CLUE reports to see your claim history. Even an inquiry about a claim, or claim with a $0 payout may appear on your record in some cases.
What Do Small Claims Look Like in Real Life?
Consider a pipe that freezes and bursts, causing a small amount of water damage. If repairs cost slightly more than your deductible, the payout may be tiny. Meanwhile, the claim could stay on your record and influence your rates for years.
Likewise, a roof patch after a windy storm may seem like an easy claim. Still, the small check you receive may not outweigh the future premium increase. Small fender benders, minor damage from a fallen tree branch, or a single pane of broken glass on a home window are also examples of minor claims you should think twice about filing. If a loss barely tops your deductible but you’re still unsure on what to do, call your agent before you file.
When Should You File a Claim Anyway?
Of course, insurance is meant for real protection, and you should never fear using it. Certainly, big losses such as a house fire or a collapsed roof are straightforward and deserve a claim. Also, liability claims, where someone else is injured, should always be reported right away. Therefore, the goal is not to avoid claims but to choose them wisely.
We typically advise that an auto claim should be at least $500 over a client’s deductible. For a home claim, that value is far higher- anywhere from $1000 to $2500 depending on the client’s deductibles.
How Do You Decide Whether to File?
Use these steps to make a clear and confident choice:
- Get estimates from professionals. Find out how much it would cost to repair the damage. (You can use this to compare to your deductible before you contact the claims department.)
- Call Your Cincinnatus Advisor. They have access to your claims record and can tell you how many times you’ve filed in your specific carrier’s guidelines.
- Now You Make the Decision: Consider the likely payout against several years of possible higher premiums and lost discounts.
- Skip Steps 1-3 if the damage is serious or others are hurt.
How Can You Prevent Small Losses?
Fortunately, you can take steps to prevent filing minor claims before they happen. Check out our blog about inspecting your own home here.
- Insulate exposed pipes and keep your home heated during long stretches of freezing weather.
- Inspect your roof each year and fix loose shingles before storms arrive.
- Consider raising your deductible to lower your premium and discourage tiny claims.
- Build a small emergency fund so minor repairs do not require a claim.
- Review your coverage yearly with an independent agent who can shop multiple carriers.
Why Work With an Independent Insurance Agent?
An independent agency like Cincinnatus Insurance works with many insurance companies instead of just one. Because of that, we can compare how each carrier treats claims history. In addition, we can guide you before you file, so you make an informed choice. If you have already filed claims that knock you out of eligibility with standard carriers, we are able to find non-standard carriers that still welcome you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will one small claim raise my premium?
It might, since many insurance carriers surcharge or remove discounts after even one claim. However, the exact effect depends on your state, your carrier, and the type of claim.
How long does a claim stay on my record?
Most claims stay on a CLUE report for up to seven years. However, many carriers focus mostly on the most recent three to five years.
Can I be non-renewed for weather-related claims?
Yes, some insurers non-renew after multiple claims, even when weather caused the damage. Rules vary by state, so ask your agent about your specific policy.
Does calling my agent count as filing a claim?
Consulting your advisor at Cincinnatus Insurance to ask a general question does not count as filing a claim.
The Bottom Line
In short, the era of filing every small claim without consequences is ending. Insurers prefer clients who file only when they really mean it, and punish those who file often. Therefore, think carefully before you file, and talk with a trusted advisor first.
